The last day of the 2011 baseball season was by all accounts the most exciting regular season day we have ever seen in the history of the game. Despite the cheap ticket grabbing existence of the wild card, the fight for the two last spots of this season will always be regarded as one of those days that even people who don’t care for the game will remember.
No team has ever been seven runs down in the last game of the season and come back to win securing a playoff berth. Yet that’s exactly what the Tampa Bay Rays did against the Yankees after starting the 2011 season by playing 62 consecutive innings without holding a lead. This was the first time the Yanks had lost a lead in the 8th inning or later since 1953. The Rays dug deep and came up with gold in outstanding fashion as Dan Johnson, who was batting .108 when he came up in the bottom of the 9th, and tied the game by hitting a homerun with two balls, two strikes and two outs. Prior to this game Johnson hadn’t hit a homerun since April 8 when he ended the aforementioned 62 game schneid with a two run knock. Evan Longoria who won the game with a walk-off homerun in the 12th now stands next to Bobby Thompson as the only players to ever hit walk-off homeruns in the final game of the season to push their team into the post-season.
In stark contrast to the Rays, no team has ever fallen as far and as fast as the Boston Red Sox did to miss the playoff cut on the last day of the season. Indeed, the Sox had not lost a game all year long in which they led in the 8th inning. That stat changed with the one game they had to win against the worst team in their division, which they lost in the 9th inning only three minutes before Longoria would hit his historic walk-off homer. No team has ever entered September in first place and finished the month with a worse record than Boston did this year (7-19). Longoria would later say he heard of the Red Sox loss as he was stepping into the batter’s box in the 12th.
The Atlanta Braves didn’t fare much better than the Sox. Their loss to the Phillies, which was the ultimate result of a blown save by rock star rookie closer Craig Kimbrel, was the third time in the last 20 days the Braves lost a game that they led in the 9th inning or later. As of September 2 the Braves lost 18 of 26 games tying the record in the National League for having the largest lead in September and not making the playoffs. This left Atlanta fans to wonder why manager Fredi Gonzalez continually played right fielding fallen star Jayson Heyward who seems to have lost his eye when phenom Jose Constanza sat on the bench. In 42 games Constanza put up a .303 average with two homeruns and 10 RBI’s. He scored 21 runs and only struck out 14 times out of 109 times at bat. The X-factor about Constanza is that he has blinding, game-changing speed that was dreadfully missing on the last days of the season.
By contrast, the St. Louis Cardinals were the recipients of Atlanta’s mismanaged disaster coming from 8 ½ games back in the wild card race to clinch on the last day.
The one word that seems to apply to every aspect of this mind numbing five hours that seared the senses of baseball fans the world over is “epic”. The individual and team performances were absolutely epic in both soul-crushing failure and glorious success. The come backs and the collapses were nothing short of epic.
However, lost in the blinding glare of the games in Baltimore, Atlanta, Tampa Bay and Houston is one other performance that was in its own right truly epic. It was the epic cowardice of New York Mets shortstop/second baseman Jose Reyes who asked to be pulled from the game in the event he got a hit in his first at bat. This was proof of the fact that there is a difference between a gifted player and a great player. In keeping with his wishes Reyes – one of the fastest players in baseball – was replaced with a pinch runner when he laid down a bunt single in the first inning against the Cincinnati Reds on the last day of the season. There was nothing wrong with this prima donna that would have precluded his ability to play. He just wanted to hedge his bets as he moved into free agency at the end of this year.
Going into the game Reyes was in a race for the National League batting title with Milwaukee Brewers third baseman Ryan Braun. Ducking out of the game like a thief in the night after going 1-for-1 secured a .337 batting average for Reyes whereas Braun, who played the whole game against the Pittsburg Pirates, went 0-for-4 finishing with a .332 average on the year. The result was the first batting title in Mets history. However, had Reyes stayed in the game and gone 1-for 4 he still would have finished two percentage points above Braun to grab the title without the ill-will that shall [hopefully] follow him around for as long as records are kept in the game of baseball.
Lou Gehrig played for the New York Yankees from 1923 to 1939. During that time he played in every game that was scheduled. While he did leave some of those games before they were over due to injury or illness, it never would have occurred to him to leave a game to protect a statistical lead in order to bolster his personal record. He didn’t need to take such a low road. Three of the top six RBI seasons in history belong to Gehrig who also holds the all time record for grand slams (23). Gehrig played with fierce competitiveness from the beginning to the end of his career when amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) finally made it impossible for him to take the field. In the end he had a .340 life time batting average with 493 homeruns, 2,171 hits, 1,995 RBI’s, an on base percentage of .447, a .632 slugging percentage and a record for consecutive games played that would stand for 56 years.
When Jackie Robinson was finally invited to play for the Brooklyn Dodgers he did so under the harshest conditions ever faced by a player in Major League Baseball before or since. He was warned by Brooklyn Dodgers’ owner Branch Rickey that he would be treated worse than he could imagine and that for the first three years he would not be allowed to respond in any way. And yet he came out on the other end of his first season with 12 home runs, a league-leading 29 stolen bases, a .297 batting average, a .427 slugging percentage, and 125 runs scored. His Herculean performance earned him the inaugural Major League Baseball Rookie of the Year Award. That is an important distinction because it wasn’t just the first time a black person won the award. It was the first time the award was presented to anyone in baseball. The first person to ever be called the Rookie of the Year in Major League Baseball was also the first black player to ever play the game.
If you take 755 homeruns out of Hank Aaron’s record you still have over 3,000 hits and let’s be very clear about the fact that Hammerin’ Hank wasn’t manipulating the game just to pad his stats for when it came time to negotiate for a batter contract. For the largest part of his career Hank Aaron couldn’t stay in the same hotel as the white players on his team. He couldn’t eat in the same restaurants or use the same restrooms. Yet he still managed to set records for RBI’S (2,297), total bases (6,856), extra-base hits (1,477) and consecutive seasons with 150 or more hits (17). And then there is the big one. As Aaron was drawing near the 715 homeruns mark he did it with enormous pressure. It wasn’t the same pressure Roger Maris dealt with when he bore down on the single season homerun record. He had to deal with death threats to himself and his family. In the famous video clip of Aaron finally touching the plate after beating Babe Ruth’s 715 record his mother rushes to him and holds him tightly as if to never let go. She would later say, “If they were going to shoot him they would have to do it through me”.
Ted Williams played the game under the nicknames “The Kid”, “The Splendid Splinter”, “Teddy Ballgame”, “The Thumper” and, the most valued of all, “The Greatest Hitter Who Ever Lived”. Williams had a life time batting average of .344 with 521 homeruns, 2,654 hits and 1,839 RBI’s. One might ask how it is that we can call this guy “The Greatest Hitter Who Ever Lived” when he fell short of the 3,000 hit club and 28 other players did not? There have also been many players with more RBI’s. It’s hard to say what would have happened had Williams not interrupted his career with a total of five years of wartime military service as an aviator in WWII and Korea. On the last day of the 1941 season Williams’ Red Sox played a double header with the Philadelphia Athletics. Williams woke up that day with a .400 average. Knowing that this was the last day of the season, player manager Joe Cronin told “The Kid” that he could sit the games out if he wanted to. But Williams refused the offer and played both games. By the end of the first game he had gone 4-for-5 finishing up with a narrow four percentage points above .400. Had he gone 0-4 in the second game of the twin bill he would have finished with a .399 average. Instead he went 2-3 and became the last player to hit over 400.
Any list of the classiest players to ever take the field has got to have Chipper Jones close to the top. He holds the Major League record for most consecutive games with an extra-base hit (14 – tied with Paul Waner). He had 8 consecutive 100-plus RBI seasons (1996–2003), 14 consecutive 20-plus homerun seasons (1995–2008); tied for the MLB record with Eddie Mathews for most 20-plus homerun seasons to start a career, and set the record for most homeruns in a season by a National League switch hitter (45 in 1999; since tied by Lance Berkman). He has the third-most home runs for a switch hitter, behind Eddie Murray (504) and Mickey Mantle (536) and he was 2008 NL (and MLB) Batting Champ with a .364 average. In 2008 Jones had the highest on-base percentage with .470 and he currently has a 29-game hitting streak against the Philadelphia Phillies who presently possess the most potent pitching battery since Maddux, Smoltz and Glavin. In 1995, he led all major league rookies in RBIs (86), games played (145), games started (123), plate appearances (602), at bats (524) and runs scored (87). That year, he finished second in Rookie of the Year balloting behind Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher Hideo Nomo.
To date Jones has 2,615 hits, 1,561 RBI’s, 526 doubles and 454 homeruns. Granted, Jones’ homerun, RBI and hits stats don’t reach those of Eddie Murray, and Mickey Mantle. However, it must be recognized that over the course of his career Jones missed 205 games primarily due to injuries. By now you have to be asking how all of this makes Jones such a class act. Simple. When he was missing game after game due to injuries many of his colleagues were bouncing right back through the use of steroids during a dark time forever known as “The Steroid Era”. Had Chipper the same low character as people like Roger Clemmons, Jose Canseco, Mark McGwire, Sammy Sosa and, of course, Barry Bonds, he would have played a vast majority of the games he missed. He also would have had a shot at eclipsing all of the records he fell short of with the added benefit of having his feet and head grow three sizes.
Instead, Jones played it straight and came up shy of those ahead of him. It’s hard to say if any of that is a consolation or helps him sleep at night. But it makes all the difference to those of us who watch closely and care.
This year Mariano Rivera crossed the threshold of 600 saves as his teammate Derek Jeeter passed the 3,000 hit mark. With one exception all of the performances and milestones listed in this piece came at the hands of men who had one thing in common. They all woke up with the intention of going out and being better than they were the day before. Yes they wanted to break and reestablish records. And those who did are proud of their accomplishments. However, it never would have occurred to Derek Jeeter, Mariano Rivera, Chipper Jones, Ted Williams, Hank Aaron, Jackie Robinson, Lou Gehrig or Ryan Braun to ever do something so cynical and cowardly as to sit out a game to manipulate their way into the record books.
They understood the only way a record can have validity is when it is compared to the odds that stand against the achievement. As the National League batting leaders went into the last day of the 2011 season they were separated by one percentage point (Braun .334, Reyes .335). To any true competitor this was an irresistible challenge. But to Reyes (and his agent) this was an opportunity to lock in a resume´ feature that would surely garner more money in his next contract. What did Mets’ management care? They were 25 games off the pace and had nothing to lose by letting “little miss thing” sit the game out. On the other hand, they would pick up their first ever batting title.
There is nothing wrong with a person in any field seeking to advance their career. In the world of sports there are many legitimate ways of doing that and they all involve performance and endurance. Babe Ruth, Ty Cobb, Mickey Mantle, Cal Ripkin, Derek Jeeter, Mariano Rivera, Chipper Jones, Ted Williams, Hank Aaron, Jackie Robinson, Lou Gehrig and many others like them reached milestones and set records against and in spite of the odds. The problem with Mark McGwire, Barry Bonds, Roger Clemons, and Jose Reyes (and by extension the clubs they played for) is that they reached milestones and set records against and in spite of the ethical notion of pure competition.
In the world of baseball wherein statistics are a point of myopic if not obsessive focus, that’s a hard bell to un-ring.